Tether Pushes Back on S&P Assessment
Tether, the company behind the world’s largest stablecoin USDT, has issued a pointed critique of S&P Global’s latest Stablecoin Stability Assessment. The rating agency assigned USDT a score of 5 on its scale—the lowest available rating—citing concerns about reserve composition and transparency. Tether’s response, which references the 2015 film “The Big Short,” signals a deepening divide between crypto-native issuers and traditional credit rating methodologies.
What the S&P Assessment Measures
S&P Global launched its Stablecoin Stability Assessment framework in 2023 to evaluate stablecoins across several dimensions: governance, reserve management, liquidity, and regulatory compliance. The scoring system runs from 1 (strongest) to 5 (weakest). According to the RSS summary from the original report, S&P made “no downward adjustment in its latest Stablecoin Stability Assessment, as 5 is the lowest available score.” This phrasing suggests USDT received the bottom rating and could not be downgraded further.
The assessment aims to provide traditional finance participants with a familiar risk framework for digital assets. However, stablecoin issuers have questioned whether legacy credit rating models adequately capture the operational realities of blockchain-based assets.
Tether’s “Big Short” Reference
Tether’s invocation of “The Big Short”—a film about investors who foresaw the 2008 housing collapse while rating agencies missed systemic risks—carries deliberate symbolism. The implication: rating agencies may again be applying outdated frameworks to novel asset classes, potentially missing actual risks while flagging theoretical ones.
The company has consistently maintained that USDT reserves are fully backed and regularly attested. As of recent attestations, reserves include U.S. Treasury bills, cash, and other short-term instruments. Tether argues that S&P’s methodology penalizes transparency about reserve composition rather than reflecting actual default risk.
Methodological Differences at Core of Dispute
The disagreement centers on fundamental questions about how to evaluate stablecoin risk. Traditional rating agencies assess counterparty credit risk, regulatory exposure, and governance structures using frameworks designed for banks and corporations. Stablecoins operate differently: they are tokenized liabilities on public blockchains with real-time reserve verification possible through on-chain data and periodic attestations.
S&P’s framework weights factors like regulatory clarity and governance transparency heavily. Tether, incorporated in the British Virgin Islands with operations across multiple jurisdictions, faces scrutiny on these dimensions regardless of reserve adequacy. The company contends that reserve quality and redemption capability—demonstrated during market stress events in 2022—should carry more weight.
Market Implications and Industry Context
USDT’s dominance in the stablecoin market—consistently above 60% market share—means rating assessments carry practical consequences. Institutional custodians, payment processors, and DeFi protocols may use S&P scores in due diligence. A low rating could complicate partnerships even if reserve adequacy is not in question.
Other major stablecoins have received varying scores under the same framework. Circle’s USDC, with its U.S. regulatory engagement and different reserve structure, has generally scored higher. The divergence reflects both structural differences and the rating agency’s weighting preferences.
What to Watch Next
Several developments could reshape this dynamic. First, S&P may refine its methodology based on industry feedback—the framework is relatively new. Second, regulatory clarity in major jurisdictions (particularly U.S. stablecoin legislation) could change how rating agencies evaluate governance and compliance factors. Third, Tether’s own transparency initiatives, including real-time reserve reporting tools, may address specific methodological criticisms.
The dispute also underscores a broader trend: as crypto assets scale, traditional financial infrastructure—rating agencies, custodians, auditors—must adapt frameworks built for different risk profiles. How this adaptation proceeds will affect not just USDT but the entire tokenized asset ecosystem.
Related reading
- Circle Earnings: Stablecoin Supply Growth Stalls as On-Chain Payments Surge
- Tether’s Q3 Profit Hits $1.5B as Excess Reserves Double to $8B
- Treasury Secretary Bessent Links Crypto to U.S. Dollar Dominance at Ripple Event
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial, investment, legal, or tax advice. Cryptocurrency investments involve risk. Conduct your own research and consult a qualified professional before making financial decisions.






























